Early NHL: The Underdog Black Hawks

In 1938, Canadians and hockey fans everywhere were shocked when one of the league’s worst teams won the Stanley Cup.

Written by Ryan Kessler

Posted April 9, 2012

Championship teams are supposed to represent the best a league has to offer. However, in 1938, Canadians and hockey fans everywhere were shocked when one of the league’s worst teams won the Stanley Cup. Not only that, but they did it with a roster some thought was nothing more than a gimmick.

Chicago Black Hawks owner Major Frederic McLaughlin decided before the 1937–38 season that he wanted his team to win a Stanley Cup with only American players — his patriotism stemmed from time he spent in the First World War.

Had McLaughlin stuck to his plan, he would’ve had only one forward, one defenseman, and one goalie. Instead, he brought in five more American players — the most of any Stanley Cup winning team.

At first, McLaughlin’s experiment seemed to be a failure. The team finished with only 14 wins in 48 games, a full 30 points behind the division-leading Boston Bruins. However, the Black Hawks were better than Detroit Red Wings by only two points, allowing them entry into the Stanley Cup Playoffs.

In the playoffs, the Black Hawks stunned the hockey world when they defeated the Montreal Canadiens and New York Americans in the first two rounds.

In the Stanley Cup Final, the Black Hawks were the clear-cut underdogs against the mighty Toronto Maple Leafs. It also didn’t help their chances that their starting goalie, Mike Karakas was taken out of the lineup with a broken toe.

Yet the Black Hawks — who had such a pitiful regular season — managed to win the next two games with minor league goaltenders. The Black Hawks lost the third game, but in the fourth, Karakas came back to win a Stanley Cup for the city of Chicago.

The 1938 Chicago Black Hawks have the worst record (14–25–9) of any team to win the Stanley Cup.

More stories about the "early NHL"

Early NHL: Spanish Flu

The Stanley Cup Finals have only been cancelled twice in the history of the NHL and first time was the 1918–1919 season when the Spanish Flu infected the Montreal Canadiens locker room.

Early NHL: Remembering Howie Morenz

Howie Morenz was ranked by The Hockey News as the 15th best player in hockey history. Yet, with all that accomplished during his life, he is still more commonly known for his untimely death.

Early NHL: Montreal 1917-1918

The 1917–1918 NHL season should’ve been one of celebration. Yet, just as the party hats and tacky commemorative coins came out, the NHL was dealt two sucker punches.

Help keep Canada’s stories strong (and free)

We hope you will help us continue to share fascinating stories about Canada’s past.


We highlight our nation’s diverse past by telling stories that illuminate the people, places, and events that unite us as Canadians, and by making those stories accessible to everyone through our free online content.


Canada’s History is a registered charity that depends on contributions from readers like you to share inspiring and informative stories with students and citizens of all ages — award-winning stories written by Canada’s top historians, authors, journalists, and history enthusiasts.


Any amount helps, or better yet, start a monthly donation today. Your support makes all the difference. Thank you! 

Related to Arts, Culture & Society